Emeralds, with their captivating green hue and timeless allure, have long been cherished as symbols of love and beauty. But when it comes to choosing between lab-created and naturally mined emeralds, the decision depends entirely on your budget and desires for an heirloom quality piece. Are lab emeralds truly better than their natural counterparts, or does the allure of authenticity outweigh the advantages of affordability? Let's explore the pros and cons of each to help you make an informed choice.
Natural Emeralds:
Pros:
- Authenticity: Natural emeralds are prized for their unique beauty, that cannot be matched like for like with lab-created alternatives. This makes them a coveted choice for those seeking a truly special and one-of-a-kind gemstone. The allure of authenticity adds to the sentimental and intrinsic value of natural emeralds.
- Rarity: Natural emeralds are renowned for their rarity, adding to their overall value. Exceptional quality AAA Grade emeralds have stunning color, clarity and brilliance, making them well suited for heirloom pieces such as an engagement ring.
- Investment Grade: Natural emeralds have a long history of being considered valuable assets, with these precious rare gems continuing to increase in value. Natural emeralds can be seen as a long-term investment, making them an ideal choice if you intend to pass down your precious heirloom ring for generations to come.
Cons:
- Cost: Due to their rare nature, good quality natural emeralds can fetch high prices, anywhere from USD$1,800 ~ USD$4,000+. Striking a good balance between price, quality and size is important, but can be achieved with the right jeweler.
Lab Emeralds:
Pros:
- Affordability: It’s no secret lab-created emeralds offer a more budget-friendly option when compared to natural emeralds. If you're price-driven and looking for the replica green color, a lab emerald might be a great choice for you, typically ranging from USD$30 ~ $100 per carat.
Cons:
- Value: Lab emeralds may offer an aesthetically pleasing center stone for their price, they do not hold any value. If you are seeking an heirloom quality gem that will hold value with a timeless, heirloom quality, then a natural emerald is your best option.
The choice between natural and lab emeralds ultimately comes down to personal preferences, budget and desired investment and meaning.
Opt for a natural emerald if:
If you are after a timeless, heirloom quality piece, with deep significance and meaning then a natural emerald is worth the investment. With enduring beauty and rarity, a natural emerald cannot be matched in both quality and aesthetic.
Opt for a lab emerald if:
If you’re looking for an affordable gemstone for a dress or cocktail ring, that has a similar green hue, then a lab-created emerald is a good choice.
When choosing your emerald be sure to consider the meaning, investment and quality of your gem, and choose the emerald that best aligns with your personal preferences. Most importantly, choose the emerald that beautifully symbolizes your love story and will be cherished for a lifetime.